It’s kind of funny, but in the over two years that I’ve been writing on this blog, I haven’t done a kitchen post, much less a kitchen renovation post. Oh, I will, I will! On my first blog which doesn’t exist any more, (thanks to that luvbucket googs and its draconian web crawler) I did a post called “No uppers.” It doesn’t exist now because of my need to purge thyself of any and all vestiges of one too many google++++ accounts which no matter how hard I tried would not go away unless I deleted EVERYTHING.
I liked that post too. It was about my love of kitchens with no upper cabinets. Like this beauty below.
One day, I’ll write another post about this because I adore kitchens without the traditional upper cabinets over the lower ones. They never existed 100 years ago.
However, this post is about something that comes up all the time. And it came up two days ago during an interior design consultation. A family of four living in an affluent area [well, it’s Westchester County, it’s ALL affluent], but in a [relatively] modest 2,500 sq. ft. house was debating whether to completely renovate their kitchen. It’s a completely individual choice, but as anyone who’s gone through it knows— it’s mighty uncomfortable, AND it’s VERY expensive.
The homeowners were given an estimate of 150k to redo a not-very-big kitchen. In the end, I advised them to do what I call a kitchen botox and facelift. Why? Their kids are 12 and 15. There is a lot to do in the home. It’s a very charming older home, but it needs some attention. AND, they only plan on being there maybe for 10 more years. Plus the cabinets just need some TLC and there was no clear advantage to renovating. In addition, they bought the home 10 years ago, when prices were near their peak.
Other considerations are:
- What did you pay for the home? Did you buy at the top of the market?
- Are other homes in your area upgrading as well or is it just you that wants to?
- Can you afford it?
I have a LOT of clients over the years who’ve gone the refurbishing route. The cabinets are fairly decent. The layout is manageable or just fine the way it is, however, there are levels. I find that the cosmetic surgery analogy fits in very nicely with these levels of pain. lol
Now, there is the “kitchen botox.” A kitchen botox is merely painting the cabinets. If you were really strapped for cash, you could do it yourself, butttt… it’s a LOT of work to do right.
Then, there’s an “eye job” with the botox and that is changing out the back splash.
The entire face would be counters and appliances and lighting.
Tummy tuck would be floors.
And some lipo in strategic spots would be not just the hardware, but things like faucets and whatnot.
In essence, everything but the cabinets. The cabinets are what cost so much and the more custom, the more expensive–of course.
A total gut reno is like a three-month stint in rehab with a facelift and all the rest. Ya come out all shiny and new, but penniless.
A lot of my clients even IF they have the money, just don’t want to put all of that into an entirely new kitchen and I have to say that I have seen amazing transformations without changing the cabinets. There is also the possibility of refacing as an alternative. That’s the full-body over-haul, minus the stint in rehab. ;]
WHAT CAN YOU DO IN THE WAY OF KITCHEN RENOVATION FOR $5,000 OR SO?
Well… it depends on the size of the kitchen. But for a small kitchen, if you do the work, you could paint, get new counters and backsplash and maybe a few other things.
What if my cabinets are laminate. Can I still paint those?
Dang it all! I had this done. We had these kinds of cabinets.
Melamine 80’s what-on-earth-were-they-not-thinking-hideousness. We lived in a townhouse and didn’t have the funds to redo the entire kitchen. However, we did a bunch of other stuff when I started my biz in ’96. We did a big botox with some tiny tucks that made a HUGE DIFFERENCE! I had the contractor nail on picture frame moulding and then he did a real number on the cabinets and spray painted them a creamy white. I was in absolute heaven. They looked great.
OMG! I found a photo of it from the old real estate listing. It’s not very big, but it’ll give you an idea of what I’m talking about and what’s possible.
These were the exact same fugly cabinets you see above. Oh, one thing. This is NOT the original paint job. After 16 years, they had chipped here and there and so they were repainted and they made them a bit too white and too shiny. [I had already moved out, so was not able to supervise this.] We also put in the black and white checkerboard floor. I have always liked that look and it suited our home, but it’s a bitch to maintain. And I had the anaglypta paper put on the ceiling. Anaglypta in case you don’t know is embossed wallpaper that can be painted to mimic an old-fashioned tin ceiling. My kids always thought it looked like paper towels. :] Similar to this one below.
I had it painted high gloss WHITE and it looked amazing. Normally, I don’t do high gloss, but I wanted to truly make the design stand out.
Here are some more ideas for a kitchen renovation on a shoestring or relatively shoestring budget.
Sophisticated Cottage/Country. I bet those cabinets are from the 50’s. They could’ve added moulding to those doors too, but in this case, a fresh coat of paint, new hardware, accessories and faucet, give the kitchen an updated look. I bet that the floor is new too.
Here is the standard oak blah cabinet! And look at the fabulous makeover the homeowners did to refresh this kitchen! Love the warmth of the butcher block counters, as well. When painting cabinets that are already not a very light color, it is sometimes best to choose a color that is darker than white. Popular colors are gray, khaki and sage green.
Today, I had a consult with a young homeowner who has a kitchen with cabinets not dissimilar to this and with the de rigueur graaaaanite counters. Her counters are not this golden, but the cabinets have that weird, coffee color glaze. I’m trying to be kind, but I am sick to death of that look. It’s done now. Amanda wants to paint the cabinets a pale gray. We looked at several grays but they all clashed with the counter and those are staying for now. We settled on one of my fabulous go-to colors. Benjamin Moore HC-172 REVERE PEWTER. It’s a warm greige color. For the walls, I suggested a darker coordinating gray, Benjamin Moore, RIVER REFLECTIONS 1552. She is also planning on taking off the decorative froo froo and I suggested putting a soffit over the cabinets. One of my pet peeves is when there’s a space above the cabinets. It always looks horrible. Then, there will be lots of creamy white trim and for the large eating area, I suggested paneled wainscoting. Pretty!
Here is a before and after. I know what you’re thinking. Except for the fact that they need to do a bit of housecleaning, what is wrong with this kitchen? Nothing. The cabinets are a warm cherry and the home has a craftsman feel that a lot of people really love. However, the owners wanted a different more contemporary look. Interesting, that they did keep one of the walls a rustic wood stain. If you check out the link, you’ll see it. I think that it was a good move. I like both looks. It’s a fabulous home. I am not positive, but I do not think that this was a full reno.
The rest of the makeovers here will feature open shelves and in most cases, that simply means taking off the doors. The kitchen above is very interesting. I have seen tile like that in a home-built in the 60’s so it might be old. Here, a new limestone counter, fabulous faucet, under-mount farmhouse sink, and stylish accessories, keep it fresh and current.
These very well, could’ve been oak, originally. Painting the back of the cabinet and shelves a deeper color when the doors are off is a great idea.
Alright, this isn’t a refurbished kitchen. However, if you had a floor to ceiling cabinet, like we had in Goldens Bridge, you could take the doors off for a similar effect. Another great upgrade, would be to add the moulding and furniture base kick.
Again, not new, but a lot of open cabinetry
new hardware makes a huge difference and is not a huge expense
Love the apple green interior paired with the soapstone counters. If you use soapstone, bear in mind that it is actually limestone and porous. However, if you used oiled soapstone, you’ll be okay, because in effect, you’re already staining it, but uniformly.
Here’s what I love about this charmer. The stove is hardly a wolf, but it looks vintage-y in this context. The cabinets are oak painted a sage green. The counters are granite, but this is one that looks perfect! The fridge is covered in chalkboard. How clever is that? My fave element is that cool, cool antique light fixture.[or at least it looks antique]. LOVE the open shelves and the white on white china and accessories. The stools are most likely from Crate and Barrel or Pottery Barn. The island? Not sure, but could even be from Ikea.
Creating a fresh new look for your kitchen does not have to cost an arm and a leg.
Maybe just an arm— or a leg :]