A Common Renovation Mess – Can it be Fixed?

freaking-out-over-your-paint-colors

 

Dear Laurel, amazing post! I am wondering if you could make a virtual renovation for Blahblah Beacon St. APT. #blah? Can it be helped? What mouldings, baseboard? And, what would you do with the design? Would you do white kitchen cabinets to the ceiling? I hear your voice lol.

 

This chandelier reminds me of your favorite one similar to Sara Jessica Parker that’s been discontinued. This could be such a fun post, and I’d love to fantasize about what can be done to make this beauty shine again! Please teach us, Laurel! I can’t wait to read all about it. hahaha.

Svetlana,

 

********

 

Darling Svet,

Be careful what you wish for. ;]

Actually, I hate it when people say that. It’s like don’t wish for anything good to come into your life, ’cause you might JUST get it. Oh, and you’ll also get some shite to go along with it. hehehe.

Well, you know what? Shite is going to happen no matter what. So, keep believing in the good!

 

Anyway, everyone, how was your Thanksgiving? Ours was tiny, but mighty tasty.

 

It was only three of us, my son, darling friend, Mary, and moi and I decided last minute that we’d just sit at the little table in my kitchen, in front of the open window.

Then, we retired to the living room for the liveliest conversation about renaissance artists, poets, and then Cale played his trombone for us, riffing on renaissance motets, Mozart, and jazz. That’s my boy! We capped that off with pumpkin pie, and my legendary (well to Cale, and I) home-made whipped cream.

 

Okay, back to BlahBlah Beacon Street – apt #.

 

I’m not putting in the address because Back Bay is tiny, and well, I don’t want folks to cower in fear when they see me coming. Really, I’m quite tolerant of most things. But, this is the work of a money-hungry opportunist. And, that bothers me. If only someone had put a little original thought into how to configure this space?

 

However, I’m not saying it’s easy to avoid a renovation mess.

 

I’ll cut them an ounce of slack there. Part of the issue is that these historic brownstone houses were never meant to be broken up into 4, 5, sometimes as many as 9 apartments in one building that was originally built for a single family.

I understand that in recent years there is a trend for many of the Brownstones to revert back to single family or two-family homes.

In addition, most brownstones, unless they are on a corner, or the apartment is taller than a neighboring building, only have windows in the front, and the back.

 

Okay. Let’s take a closer look at BlahBlah Beacon. And, before we talk about the renovation mess, let’s go over what’s wonderful about it.

 

One. You already know.

LOCATION. With it’s proximity to the public garden, Boston Common, Charles River, Beacon Hill, Newbury Street, Downtown, the north end, the south end, this is an incredible address. Actually, anywhere in Back Bay is.

 

back bay brownstones

The exterior is quite lovely. Well, the front of the building is.

 

The back could use some help. No?

 

Then, the two bedrooms each have French doors with [swoon] transom windows.

 

master bedroom - French doors - Transom windows

 

guest bedroom den - French Doors Transom Windows

 

Remember this post about transom windows. I adore them! And, I have one of my own now in my new bedroom.

 

renovation mess floor plan

Above is the floor plan. Unusual layout. But, observe how the kitchen is eating up the living room.

 

renovation mess - living room - kitchen - weird fireplaceThis building was constructed in the 1860s, and one of the first homes built in Back Bay. There is no vestige of anything from that period.

That fireplace wall is making me crazy.

 

Really crazy.

 

enovation mess - kitchen - living room - front doorI’m trying to wrap my mind around what is actually going on there. There is the chimney flue, but the mantel isn’t centered on it. No way is that the original mantel.

 

fireplace mantel wall

Let’s take a closer look at that stone mantel.

 

renovation mess-ungapotched fireplace mantelThat is some seriously strange going on there.

For exquisite stone fireplace mantels, please go here.

But, there’s also the ugliest stone fireplace you’ve ever seen.

 

bad decorating - big black sofa - purple rug
There’s our BIG BLACK SOFA.

That SHINY PURPLE rug. Or maybe I should say R-UGH.

Why is everything lined up on one end of the coffee table? Maybe they should take a look at how to style a coffee table. I’m far from perfect, but that is just plain weird.

 

The bigger question is this.

 

Why did someone turn this historical 19th century beauty in a prime Boston location into a contemporary bastion of bad taste? And, this baby sold for well over one million dollars.

LOCATION. I know.

But still…

Let’s see what the MLS had to say in the listing.

 

Spectacular sun-filled home with soaring ceilings in a Historic 1860’s Boston brownstone offering gracious living in the Back Bay’s most prestigious location; the first block!

 

bad moulding - renovation mess
Well, “sunfilled” is a north-facing living room, and “soaring” until we get to the air conditioning duct-work, and a hugely dropped ceiling. To dress it up, I guess, they stuck an eccentric crown moulding across the bottom. But, shame, they obviously didn’t order enough, and it just ends long before it should. Oh, well, we’ll just put a return on it, and then it’ll look intentional, like the ungapatched fireplace.

wtf???

I’m sorry, but not really. This is not gracious. The front door opens straight into the kitchen which is chowing down the living room for its breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

 

So bad. And, unfortunately, all too common amongst many a misguided renovation mess. Fortunately, not all apartments are like this.

They go on to say:

 

A highly coveted address steps from Boston Garden, Boston Common, Charles River Esplanade, Charles Street & Newbury Street’s designer shopping, and fine dining, all this with convenient access to Storrow Drive, and public transportation.

 

YES, YES, YES, AND YES!!! All true. So, why is this gem not treated with greater respect?

 

Exquisite features of this home include: central air-conditioning, hardwood flooring, crown molding, and recessed lighting,

 

[Excuse me. There is nothing exquisite about recessed lighting.]

 

large front-facing living room with windows looking onto Beacon Street, two south facing bedrooms with stone fireplace, exposed brick, and private outdoor deck with city views. The home features one full, and one half bathroom, in-unit washer/dryer, and a well-appointed kitchen with: modern light-oak colored cabinets, stainless oven & cook top, black granite counter-tops, and marble backsplash.

 

Blah, blah… and, you’re lying. That kitchen is anything but well-appointed. It could be, but in its current state, it’s not.

 

With over 1,133+ Square Feet – the home offers ample space to live comfortably.

 

It’s not the amount of space. It’s HOW the space is used.

 

This 6-unit building is self-managed with a high owner-occupancy. OWNERS RELOCATING

 

Well, of course, they’re relocating! haha

 

Okay, let’s look at the floor plan again.

 

renovation mess floor plan
Here, you can see clearly that the entrance, indeed, opens straight into the kitchen. Horrendous. It’s like they tried to turn a two-bedroom into a studio apartment. To the left of the kitchen is a large open-plan living, dining room. To the right of the kitchen is a washer, dryer. That’s nice, but there is about 12 sq feet of wasted space in front of it.

I like that they do have a half bath, and that the full bath is both ensuite, and accessible from the hall.

 

The second thing that is screaming out at me is that there isn’t any bloody storage in this place.

 

I mean, it’s a TWO BEDROOM. And, there is a closet for each bedroom, and one tiny linen closet, and that’s it.

Where do they put their shit?

I mean, their coat closet?

Utility closet? broom? mop? bucket? step ladder? vacuum cleaner?

What about a pantry? That is a tiny kitchen. The island is taking up valuable real estate, as well.

Today, I’m not going to get into the specifics of the design; like colors, and mouldings; that’s easy. If I can only solve the renovation mess, I will be a happy girl. The way it is, right now, is inexcusable.

 

So, I took this floor plan, and had my way with it.

 

My first objective was to create a sense of entrance where the occupants don’t feel like they’re walking STRAIGHT into the kitchen. The second objective was to at least double if not triple the amount of storage space. And, do so without sacrificing valuable living space.

The third goal is to fix that mess of a fireplace wall.

And, the fourth is to stop that kitchen from encroaching on the living room space.

Other objectives were to create a more pleasing furniture layout and, finally, address the big blank wall in the back of the room. Remember when we talked about those pesky big, blank living room walls?

 

Did I do it?

 

Let’s take a look.

 


I overlaid a little grid over over the plan to make sure my measurements were accurate to within an inch or two.

 

Okay, let’s begin with the major changes.

 

First, I eliminated that silly little laundry room. And, I relocated a single washer/dryer unit that can live behind a cabinet door, in the kitchen adjacent to the sink. They make them as shallow as 22 inches, and they are ventless. Now that I got rid of the laundry room, I was able to move the kitchen over where it belongs, and now I am able to center the fireplace, and flank it with two bookshelves. However, I created a matching fireplace flu on the leftside  of the fireplace mantel.

Above this area, I placed four library sconces.

 

Can I tell you how much better I feel, already?

 

We can put a series of three prints on the blank wall, both of them. And, I would also love to see a wainscoting panel go around the room.

 

Pondfield Rd Bronxville apartment for sale - living room - entry - Benjamin Moore AmericaMaybe something like the three antique prints I have in my current living room.

 

Please look at my living room in Back Bay for an example of beautiful, classical wainscoting. You know. I can’t believe I own this! For more information about wainscoting, please check out one of my favorite posts.

 

I’ll keep bringing back the floor plan so you don’t have to get dizzy scrolling back, and forth.

 

 

The living room is 19 feet deep.

 

Therefore, I know that there is enough room for the dining area to go behind the new seating area. I think a round 48″-54″ table with leaves would be terrific. In the back, I added built-in glass-door china cabinets. However, they could also be free-standing. In addition, I would like them to light up.

 

And, now, we’re coming to my favorite part of this renovation mess fix.

 

Out of that corner where the dining area formerly was, I created both a pantry, and a good-sized utility closet. This is what is sorely missing from this place.

Across from the utility closet is a coat closet, and the back of the fridge. Well, there’s a wall there, but over the wall, I created a fake door to match the coat closet door. Those doors match the double doors of the utility closet, directly across.

NOW, when we come in, our eye will move towards the closet doors, and light coming from the windows, if during the day.

 

The rest of the kitchen is lower cabinets only except for maybe the sink wall. We could do upper glass front cabinets here (except over the sink).

 

We got rid of that honking huge fridge, and did a counter depth fridge. I indicated a fairly wide one, but it could be more narrow, too.

 

 

The counter adjacent to the living room is open. And, despite my belly-aching, lol, I did add two counter stools. Now everyone can be happy. In fact, if we have a chef who prefers not to have guests around, she/he can hide the stools and put up some beautiful bi-fold glass windows, and shut everyone out.

The only other thing I added was a funny little closet in that odd space off the master bedroom.

 

This is now an apartment I’d seriously consider purchasing, if I didn’t already have one I love.

 

Oh man, I’m lovin’ that pantry, and utility closet.

I didn’t touch the bedrooms. They are delightfully quirky.

However, the balcony could certainly use some help. However, with a bit of repair-work, new paint, lovely planters and furniture, I think it could look terrific.

I hope you enjoyed this exercise. I think it shows that even if you come across a place that isn’t quite working for you, and you can’t figure it out, I would hire an interior designer or architect to help you reconfigure it. Some builders are also very good at this. Some are, and some aren’t; just like with everything.

In closing, please check out the HOT SALES pages for great cyber Monday (and week) deals, and HOLIDAY SHOP.

 

***And, also, I just released my new 80-page Etsy Guide with over 150 Vendors.***

 

It’s yours for FREE if you purchase any of my interior design guides.

 

In addition, if you purchase any of the guides, you’ll get the 333 Rules and Tips You Need to Know for FREE, too!

This is only for a limited time, however. In a few weeks, the price of the Rules & Tips, and the new Etsy Guide will be going up in price.

xo,

 

 

 

7th edition rolodex-post-graphic - November 2020 - A unique shopping guide with hundreds of sources created by Laurel Bern

  • Lily - December 1, 2020 - 11:34 AM

    This is great! Weird rooms are so tough.

    I have a question about your complaint of the front door opening onto the kitchen.

    I have a galley (8′ x 10′) that is adjacent to a tiny entry (4’10 x 5′) that’s more of a windowless vestibule than anything else. Well, the front door has a window, but the door is in a cove and it’s. Ugh.

    Anyway.

    I was thinking about removing the wall that splits these two and turning the stove and counter on that side into an island. It would make the kitchen appear much bigger and more open, and it would win me some inches for entry storage that’s eaten up by wall right now.

    Would that be horrible? I know you can’t really give specific advice, but are all front doors entering kitchens bad?ReplyCancel

    • Laurel Bern - December 1, 2020 - 9:45 PM

      Hi Lily,

      The reason I can’t give advice is because I can’t see what you’re talking about. It’s impossible for me to visualize a situation from a description. I’m sorry.ReplyCancel

  • Vicki D Whiteside - December 1, 2020 - 1:11 AM

    I apologize that was uncalled for. I do love your blog.ReplyCancel

  • Vicki D Whiteside - December 1, 2020 - 1:04 AM

    Your problems are quite small in the whole scheme of thingsReplyCancel

  • John Lee - November 30, 2020 - 11:42 PM

    Thanks for the fun post, Laurel! What an atrocity – the LR fireplace looks like it’s going to slide away!ReplyCancel

  • Carolina V G - November 30, 2020 - 9:31 PM

    You are great Laurel!
    Funny and intelligent!ReplyCancel

  • Kathleen Murphy - November 30, 2020 - 8:15 PM

    Great new floor plan! With that two door hatch in the dropped ceiling I’m guess that’s where the AC unit is. Horrible! I’d move it to above the new broom closet or pantry, with the return vent facing out into hall above closet doors. This removes all of that big drop ceiling, even in the hallway! Eliminate the round AC tube ducts, switching to a very shallow 1 slot 3″ high linear diffusers. It’s updated, quieter & has better air flow. Then you’d have a new very shallow drop ceiling. So shallow I’d bring new venting/ceiling height all the way to windows and back along the hallway to reach the entry to bedrooms and baths. I’d keep the uppers in kitchen but remove those soffits and maybe bring cabinets to new higher ceiling!ReplyCancel

  • Gaye - November 30, 2020 - 2:58 PM

    I love that phrase “in my Backbay living room.” The “my” part esp.ReplyCancel

  • Lira - November 30, 2020 - 2:18 PM

    Laurel,
    How can I get interior decorating advice if we don’t have a lot of money? Is there a course I can take or some way to make a more cohesive overall plan? I read your article about decorating on a shoe string for ideas, but I need an over arching plan. Do you have some suggestions?ReplyCancel

    • Laurel Bern - November 30, 2020 - 2:28 PM

      Hi Lira,

      Most designers will work on a consultation basis. It is money well-spent because very often they can save you money. Or, when you go to sell, help you create something which will give you a better return on your investment. Of course, that may or may not be the case.ReplyCancel

  • Marji - November 30, 2020 - 2:16 PM

    Has anyone suggested the w/d go in the MBR closet next to the sink and a second closet be added on the other side of the FP? I guess it depends on how much counter space you need in the kitchen vs the need for clothes storage. Obviously the best place is taking half of the utility closet if the plumbing works. We had that in a condo once and it was very handy.ReplyCancel

    • Laurel Bern - November 30, 2020 - 2:26 PM

      Hi Marji,

      The washer/dryer unit in the kitchen goes under the counter, so no loss of counter space. And, it is shallow enough to have a door covering it, as well. But, yes, ideally, it would go in the utility closet and be a stackable washer/dryer.ReplyCancel

  • Mary Ann - November 30, 2020 - 11:17 AM

    Was just perusing the internet and saw some of the lovely work of Christina Wikman… worth a look as you think about your new place!

    ReplyCancel

  • Gail - November 29, 2020 - 9:34 PM

    Brilliant. LOVE how you are not restricted by ideas like pantry must be in or beside kitchen. I never would have thought to switch dining and living. I learn so much from you.
    Moving W/D is definitely dependent on plumbing, access and budget. I’m so lucky to be married to a plumber!ReplyCancel

  • Christine - November 29, 2020 - 6:15 PM

    Could you stack the W/D in the coat closet and use the utility closet for both coats and vacuum cleaner/broom storage?ReplyCancel

  • Sheree L - November 29, 2020 - 6:07 PM

    Your solutions are brilliant! The new floor plan is 100% better than the old one. It is such a shame that these beautiful apartments are renovated without a bit more consideration such as you have shown us here.ReplyCancel

  • Sue DURTSCHE - November 29, 2020 - 5:57 PM

    I agree- I was thinking you could put the door into the WD where it was to enter from the bathroom and then the left in there could be storage shelves. Those ventless machines are a fire waiting to happen with the lint build up.ReplyCancel

  • George W Lennon - November 29, 2020 - 4:45 PM

    Good work. Whenever I see a dropped ceiling in an older building, I am tempted to look above the sheetrock. Sometimes, a high ceiling and crown are hidden. Ductwork and wiring can usually be rerouted to reveal the original architecture. Cheers!ReplyCancel

  • Rita Brantley - November 29, 2020 - 3:02 PM

    Love seeing you take on making something functional and fabulous.ReplyCancel

  • cyd - November 29, 2020 - 3:02 PM

    Oh, I love this! My only quibble would be the W/D. Not only would I dislike it in the kitchen, there are big negatives to ventless, chiefly the lint. We took them out of our rentals for this very reason. I do realize, however, that any move of piping will entail cost. Everything is a trade off.ReplyCancel

  • Christine - November 29, 2020 - 1:46 PM

    I’m in awe of your ability to visualize your ideas. This is a brilliant plan. Like others have mentioned, the washer/dryer would ideally be better in the broom closet, but only if you can get water to it. You’re on a roll Laurel, keep your creative juices flowing.ReplyCancel

  • Lynda - November 29, 2020 - 1:27 PM

    Blahblah Beacon…you are so funny! My pet peeve is that big honking fridge sticking out into the room.ReplyCancel

  • Laurel Bern - November 29, 2020 - 12:57 PM

    I’ll reply more later. I did consider the utility room, butwe need a water supply for the washing machine. That might be possible in the utility closet. After all, there’s 3 feet of crawl space above the kitchen/ entry. If so, then definitely yes, it should go in the new closet.ReplyCancel

  • Linda D. - November 29, 2020 - 11:00 AM

    I’m with you, Sue – I think this is brilliant space planning. I may be brave enough to tackle my own vision board, but space planning is the single biggest issue I want a professional for. I need a professional to see through previous mistakes and show me what is possible with the square footage available.ReplyCancel

  • Kristin - November 29, 2020 - 10:37 AM

    What an improvement! The one change I’d make is to put the washer and dryer stacked in the utility closet rather than the kitchen. I had this layout in an apartment once, and it worked well as on laundry day I the space around the closet to work, fold, sort, etc.. I wouldn’t want to do that in the kitchen.ReplyCancel

  • Maggie S - November 29, 2020 - 10:28 AM

    WOW what an incredible change!! I hope you will do this again, it was fun to see how the changes made it into a welcoming livable place instead of feeling disjointed.ReplyCancel

  • Kathy - November 29, 2020 - 10:17 AM

    You did a fantastic job on this darling condo !!!
    I have always lived in a two story 1930 English Tudor. No pantry and no closets.
    We are looking to move into a smaller old home. And I will keep this in mind.
    So thank you for sharing.
    Sincerely thanks, KathyReplyCancel

  • Monica - November 29, 2020 - 9:27 AM

    If there are unlimited funds available here than go for the full remodel! But if not, maybe just replace the refrigerator and make some cosmetic changes to get this space more to your liking. The white cabinets are already a major improvement! I’d consider moving the dining table to the area near the fireplace, keeping it slightly off center, and putting a chair or something in the narrow space to the right of the fireplace, which will definitely need a new mantel piece. This change allows for a natural extension of the kitchen. The living room, including the TV, could then go in the larger area to the left of the entry and allows the cook to enjoy whatever may be streaming at any given time. Painting the entire space the same color would go a long way to improving the fireplace wall. Oh, and select more period appropriate lighting!ReplyCancel

  • Janet R - November 29, 2020 - 9:09 AM

    So fun to look at and think about!ReplyCancel

  • Elle - November 29, 2020 - 8:44 AM

    (This was a reply to Su An Carey)ReplyCancel

  • Elle - November 29, 2020 - 8:43 AM

    One issue with this is that the living room has a lovely view of the street, while the bedrooms overlook the alley, which is not nearly so attractive. The layout you suggest is popular on the other side of the street, where the buildings back on to the Charles River Esplanade. Another issue is noise. Alleys can be loud with truck delivering to commercial buildings and early-morning trash pickup. And they can be dark. On the other hand, Beacon Street itself can be noisy, with constant traffic, etc., especially on this block. This block happens to have many college buildings, so it is lively with students at most hours, partying on weekends, etc. (Locals know to avoid moving to this block.)

    While it’s important to have a great layout inside, one also has to consider the orientation to the outside, especially in a dense urban neighborhood.ReplyCancel

  • Elle - November 29, 2020 - 8:31 AM

    Oh, Laurel! Where have you been all my life? In the first paragraphs, I felt like I was reading a post I’d written about the horrors of our local RE. Word for word! But I lack your imagination and design skills to improve them. I wish you had moved here decades ago, when you could have inspired more developers to design lovely living spaces to suit these Back Bay buildings. I think yours is a brilliant solution. I hope the developers start paying attention.

    My only quibble is that usually only one person or a couple live in 2BRs here, so the half bath might be more useful as additional storage. I know that’s controversial and affects resale value, but I’ve lived in apartments like these for 40 years, with a husband and one bath, and we survived. It helps that our bath is roomy, with excellent storage. I prefer the W/D there because ventless dryers coat everything with a layer of lint, which would be even more of a pain to clean in the kitchen. I have dreams about finding another closet in here; I never dream about finding a half-bath. But we’re not all the same! Anyway, I am SO glad you are here! Welcome, welcome!ReplyCancel

  • Dmiko - November 29, 2020 - 7:51 AM

    Brava!!!ReplyCancel

  • Sue Walter - November 29, 2020 - 7:04 AM

    Genius space planning, Laurel! Such an improvement. Pantries rule!ReplyCancel

  • Annie L. - November 29, 2020 - 6:30 AM

    Good morning! SOOO happy you had a lovely Turkey Day with your sweet boy and gal pal. Thank you for making my day the BEST with your shtick! Beautiful work, Laurel! 💋ReplyCancel

  • su an carey - November 29, 2020 - 5:07 AM

    I do see if this is rented or owned- if owned- since the bathroom is mid space, I would use the bedroom as the living room and the back room as the library/sitting rm, tv etc. If you need two BR’s keep the back one, but if one BR will do remove the wall between the two. Now you have a LR with Porch. The Front door should direct you down a fancied up hall past the Kitchen.ReplyCancel

  • Kim Doyle - November 29, 2020 - 4:59 AM

    Laurel, Incredible! Such an impressive re-think of this space to make it beautiful and livable. One question – what is with the dropped ceiling over the current kitchen and dining area – could/should that be raised up to the same height as the main living space?ReplyCancel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.